CMS Proposes REAL Health Providers Act Rule for MA Directories
The proposed rule targets Medicare Advantage ghost networks with 90-day updates, annual accuracy reporting, and PBM reforms.
CMS published a proposed rule on October 20 that implements three major provisions of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026: the REAL Health Providers Act targeting Medicare Advantage “ghost networks,” new pharmacy benefit manager transparency requirements, and a $0 generic copay for low-income dual-eligible enrollees 1. For health plans, directory API vendors, and anyone building on MA network data, the rule introduces verification and maintenance standards, annual accuracy analysis and reporting, and public reporting of accuracy scores that take effect in contract year 2028 — with public display of machine-readable scores required by 2029 1.
Key takeaways - MA organizations must verify and update provider directories at least every 90 days, conduct annual accuracy analysis and reporting to CMS, and prominently display those scores publicly starting in 2029 12. - Enrollees who receive care from an out-of-network provider due to directory inaccuracies would pay only in-network cost-sharing amounts 12. - PBMs in Part D would be limited to flat service fees untied to drug prices, rebates, or formulary placement, with annual compensation and performance reporting to plan sponsors and CMS 12.
What the REAL Health Providers Act requires
Section 6220 of the CAA, titled the Requiring Enhanced and Accurate Lists of (REAL) Health Providers Act, directs CMS to establish provider directory verification and maintenance standards, annual accuracy analysis and reporting, public reporting of accuracy scores, and cost-sharing protections for enrollees who rely on inaccurate directory information 1. The proposed rule codifies these requirements for contract year 2028, with additional provisions for contract year 2029 including CMS public display of accuracy scores in machine-readable format and MA organizations prominently displaying those scores in their directories 1.
Verification cadence and accuracy scoring
The rule would require MA plans to check directory accuracy and update entries at least once every 90 days — a significant increase from the current requirement to update within 30 days of learning of changes and attest annually 2. Plans must also conduct annual accuracy analysis and reporting to CMS 12. Those scores would also be “prominently displayed” on public-facing directories so beneficiaries can assess reliability over time 5. CMS has been working toward a national provider directory, and the data collected under this rule could feed that infrastructure 2.
Cost-sharing protection for enrollees
If an enrollee relies on inaccurate directory information and receives care from an out-of-network provider, the proposed rule would limit the enrollee’s cost-sharing to the in-network amount 12. This protection addresses a core harm of ghost networks: patients who believe they are seeing an in-network clinician and later receive a surprise bill.
PBM transparency and compensation reform
Section 6224 of the CAA targets pharmacy benefit manager practices in Medicare Part D. The proposed rule would: - Limit PBM remuneration to flat service fees reflecting fair market value, prohibiting fees based on drug price, rebates, or formulary placement 12. - Require PBMs to report compensation and cost performance data annually to Part D plan sponsors and CMS 12. - Mandate transparency in price guarantee arrangements between PBMs and plan sponsors 1. - Require disclosure of terms of certain agreements between PBMs and pharmaceutical manufacturers 1. - Establish compliance and enforcement mechanisms including disgorgement of funds for violations of remuneration requirements 1.
Generic copay elimination for low-income dual eligibles
Section 6219 reduces the generic drug copayment from $1 to $0 for full-benefit dual-eligible individuals with incomes at or below 100% of the federal poverty level, effective for plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2028 1. CMS estimates approximately 6 million enrollees would be affected based on 2026 enrollment data 1. The CPI inflation adjustment methodology would continue to apply only to plan years before 2028 for this population 1.
Historical context: the scope of the problem
CMS’s own reviews have documented persistent directory inaccuracies. In its third review round (November 2017–July 2018), covering 52 MA organizations, 5,602 providers, and 10,504 locations, 48.74% of locations had at least one inaccuracy 3. The deficiency rate by MAO ranged from 4.63% to 93.02%, with an average of 44.97% 3. High-severity deficiencies — those most likely to block access to care — appeared in 41.75% of all locations 3. A 2023 study cited in trade coverage found upwards of 80% of provider listings contained inconsistencies 2.
Timeline and next steps
- Comment deadline: 5 p.m. Eastern Standard Time, December 15, 2026 1.
- Effective date for heightened directory standards, cost-sharing protections, and PBM requirements: Contract year 2028 (marketing and communications policies apply beginning October 1, 2027) 12.
- Public display of accuracy scores in machine-readable format and prominent directory display: Contract year 2029 1.
- $0 generic copay for qualifying dual eligibles: Plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2028 1.
What this means in practice
For MA plans and their technology teams: Build or procure directory verification workflows that can run on a 90-day cycle, produce a standardized accuracy score, and feed both CMS reporting and public display endpoints.
For directory API vendors and data aggregators: The machine-readable score display requirement in 2029 implies a schema and API contract. Expect CMS to publish technical specifications; track the comment period for clues on format (FHIR-based is a reasonable bet given ONC’s direction).
For PBMs and Part D sponsors: Flat-fee compensation models require renegotiating contracts and building new reporting pipelines for annual compensation and cost-performance disclosures. The disgorgement provision adds enforcement teeth.
For providers and provider-data managers: The 90-day verification cycle means your demographic and network-status updates must be ingestible by plans on at least a quarterly cadence. Inaccurate data will show up in plan scores — and those scores will be public.
Our read
The rule signals CMS’s intent to treat provider directories as regulated data products with SLAs, not static PDFs. The 90-day cycle, public scoring, and cost-sharing backstop create aligned incentives: plans that invest in automated verification and real-time provider-data feeds will score better and avoid financial exposure. For vendors, the machine-readable score mandate in 2029 is the hook — whatever format CMS specifies will become the de facto integration standard.
What we’d watch
- Whether the final rule specifies the accuracy-score methodology (weighting, denominator, provider types) or leaves it to sub-regulatory guidance.
- How CMS defines “flat service fee” for PBMs — the fair-market-value standard will likely spur litigation over methodology.
- Comments from MAOs on the 90-day operational lift, especially for plans with narrow or multi-state networks.
- Whether the national provider directory effort gets legislative funding or remains aspirational.
Sources
- Medicare Program; Implementation of Sections 6219, 6220, and 6224 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026 — Federal Register, 2026-10-20
- CMS proposes rule to clean up MA provider directories, shine light on PBMs — Healthcare Dive, 2026-10-19
- https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Health-Plans/ManagedCareMarketing/Downloads/Provider_Directory_Review_Industry_Report_Round_3_11-28-2018.pdf — cms.gov
- CMS proposes Medicare Advantage provider directory, PBM rule - Modern Healthcare — modernhealthcare.com, 2026-10-16
- CMS proposes new regulations to eliminate ‘ghost networks’ and improve PBM transparency — healthexec.com, 2026-10-16
Researched and drafted with AI from the sources above, and checked claim by claim against them before publishing.